The Washington Publish Continues to Expose Florida’s Failed Insurance coverage Regulation | Property Insurance coverage Protection Regulation Weblog


The Washington Publish investigates authorities corruption and incompetence. Whereas these investigations are usually on the nationwide degree, the Washington Publish continues to indicate how Florida’s insurance coverage regulators are failing Florida’s residents in the case of property insurance coverage oversight and safety. Right now’s article, How Florida Let a Prime Insurer Abandon Owners in Their Time of Biggest Want,1 is a must-read for everyone buying insurance coverage in Florida.


The article acknowledged partly:

Michael Yaworsky, Florida’s new insurance coverage commissioner, stated that state regulators had been on high of monitoring UPC’s habits and financials. In an interview, he defined how his workplace was ‘fairly aggressive when it got here to our response to the evolving state of affairs with United and UPC.’

‘We met the second every time one thing developed,’ he stated of UPC’s struggles.

A giant drawback, Yaworsky identified, is that his workplace had been restricted in what they might do relating to how mother or father corporations act and what they do with their cash. He pointed to latest laws, together with the brand new Insurer Accountability Act, that has given his company extra sources and attain to higher govern insurers, although the hardest provisions of the legislation have been stripped from the ultimate model. Officers have now pledged to totally examine UPC’s conduct and any allegations of dangerous habits.

UPC’s enterprise mannequin, insurance coverage and monetary specialists say, displays a lax regulatory framework that has made it even more durable for Florida residents to get again on their toes after disasters.

‘Insurance coverage corporations have been given large quantity of leeway in Florida,’ Birny Birnbaum, the director of the Middle for Financial Justice and a former insurance coverage regulator stated in an interview. ‘Mild regulation let these smaller corporations are available and cherry decide what they need to cowl. When there isn’t a hurricane, they will make an incredible amount of cash. When there’s one, executives can stroll away with out a lot legal responsibility and quite a bit richer.’

UPC was the insurance coverage firm I referred to as out for wrongly denying claims on a systemic foundation in Zeroed Out Hurricane Claims and Dishonest Claims Practices—Why Are Our Florida Politicians Ignoring These Ongoing Claims Issues and Seemingly Defending Dishonest Insurance coverage Firms. I criticized Florida’s legislators and regulators for not taking motion or making legal guidelines to guard Floridians from such wrongful conduct. The reality is almost all of Florida’s present legislators handed extra legal guidelines to guard UPC and different wrongfully appearing insurance coverage corporations. Yaworksy and Florida’s legislators know that the complete extent of the laws took away policyholder rights and that the so-called Accountability Act is a whole sham made for public relations.

The Washington Publish article famous that neither Jimmy Patronis nor the Workplace of Insurance coverage Regulation did something about these wrongful actions:

Patronis by no means responded…The Division of Monetary Companies, which Patronis oversees, stated that it seemed into Buvens’s allegations in 2021 however closed the probe attributable to his ‘lack of cooperation’ for an interview. The adjuster rejected that declare, saying he was residing in Texas and couldn’t go to Florida on the proposed dates attributable to earlier commitments, and provided to do a digital interview. His a number of follow-up emails to the workplace went unanswered, he stated.

‘I merely wished Jimmy Patronis and the DFS to do their job that they have been elected to do,’ Buvens stated in an interview. ‘Examine the executives of this insurance coverage firm to forestall them from persevering with to prey on the policyholders and property house owners in Florida.’

That very same month, the American Policyholder Affiliation, a nonprofit watchdog with a shopper safety unit led by a former prosecutor, despatched two complaints to regulators alleging that UPC altered claims and advised adjusters to ‘zero out’ harm. The complaints have been despatched to the Workplace of Insurance coverage Regulation, which regulates carriers, and the Division of Monetary Companies, which investigates allegations of wrongdoing. The letters, reviewed by The Publish, contained depositions, telephone interview transcripts, estimates, engineer reviews and emails.

For months, officers on the two businesses punted the proof backwards and forwards, based on the sequence of emails obtained by The Publish spanning from 2021 to proper earlier than Ian hit final 12 months. In a single a part of the change, at finish of January 2022, a Division of Monetary Companies investigator confirmed that the company had acquired the proof months in the past, however thought the Workplace of Insurance coverage Regulation ought to deal with it. 5 months later, in June, the watchdog checked in. This time, an Workplace of Insurance coverage Regulation official stated the Division of Monetary Companies ought to deal with it, solely to obtain a response from the Division of Monetary Companies that they’d already mentioned the state of affairs:

‘Should you recall, we spoke a number of weeks in the past about this similar referral and it was determined OIR would initially look into the allegations,’ based on the e-mail, which The Publish obtained from the policyholder affiliation.

The e-mail change went useless. The Workplace of Insurance coverage Regulation stated it didn’t become involved as a result of it had already been monitoring the corporate for different causes.

My hat is off to the work of the American Policyholder Affiliation (APA) for serving to expose this fraud towards policyholders. The following annual assembly of the APA might be in Dallas on November 1-3.

The Washington Publish and reporter Brianna Sacks must be congratulated for his or her follow-up to their earlier article famous in Wanna Make a Wager Whether or not DeSantis/Patronis Insurance coverage Firm Investigation Finds Extra Corruption Than One Washington Publish Reporter Will Discover. The Washington Publish gained that wager.

Thought For A Friday Afternoon

Newspapers which might be actually unbiased, like The Washington Publish, can nonetheless aggressively examine anybody or something with no holds barred.

—Bob Woodward

1 Brianna Sacks. How Florida let a high insurer abandon householders of their time of biggest want. Washington Publish. Aug. 4, 2023. Accessible on-line at: (final seen August 4, 2023).


Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *